CatTwig Alternatives (Top 10 Picks)

Thinking about trying silvervine sticks for your cat but not totally sold on CatTwig? A lot of cat parents start with raw bark-on silvervine, but later look for something with better scent, more textures, fewer dud sticks, and more predictable reactions.

CatTwig is fine for simple, natural silvervine… but it’s definitely not the only option. And if your cat needs something stronger-smelling, more consistent, or just more interesting to chew, there are plenty of better alternatives to explore.

Here are the best CatTwig alternatives to help you find something that fits your cat’s play style.

Best CatTwig Alternatives

These are the top options if you want something different from (or possibly better than) CatTwig.

1. NomSticks Silvervine Sticks for Cats

If you want the most reliable alternative to CatTwig, NomSticks is the clear standout.

CatTwig sticks are raw and unsorted, so the experience can be hit-or-miss. 

NomSticks solves that by checking every single stick by hand for proper thickness, scent strength, safe finishing, and clean construction. 

Because the sticks are paired with natural sisal rope and raffia, your cat gets multiple textures to chew, grab, shred, and hold... keeping cats engaged longer.

NomSticks is the best pick if you want something that feels genuinely well-made instead of random.

2. Meowijuana Silvervine Sticks

Meowijuana sells thick, bark-on silvervine sticks with a naturally decent aroma. They’re usually more consistent than generic sticks, and many cats enjoy the rugged, raw texture. You’ll still need to scrape them to activate the scent, and some cats lose interest if the bark is too tough.

A good “simple but better sorted” option if your cat prefers natural wood.

3. Meowy Janes Silvervine + Gall Fruit

Meowy Janes sells thin pieces of silvervine coated in gall fruit powder. The powder gives a very strong, immediate scent hit that many cats respond to right away. Just keep in mind the powder is messy and wears off quickly, so the fun doesn’t last as long.

Ideal for smell-driven cats, less ideal for cats who like to chew for dental benefits.

4. Twin Critters KittiKrack

KittiKrack is pure silvervine powder, not a stick at all, and it consistently delivers fast, intense reactions. Cats often roll, zoom, and rub all over it within seconds. But since there’s nothing to chew, it offers zero dental benefits and doesn’t provide long-term engagement.

Great for quick, high-energy enrichment but not for longer sessions or chewers.

5. Potaroma Silvervine Sticks

Potaroma is a large Amazon brand known for its rope-and-raffia silvervine sticks. Many packs have stronger scent than generic multipacks, and lots of cats enjoy the flossy textures. The downside is that consistency varies a lot — sizing, finishing, and aroma strength can swing pack to pack.

A solid “grab-and-go” budget pick as long as you don’t expect perfect quality control.

6. Purriq Silvervine Sticks

Purriq uses bark-on silvervine sticks with simple rope and raffia details. They’re slightly cleaner than the cheapest Amazon bundles and work fine for casual enrichment. But like many mass-market options, the scent varies a lot, and you’ll still run into uneven or low-aroma pieces.

A straightforward alternative if you want something familiar, inexpensive, and easy to test.

7. Purralux Silvervine Sticks

Purralux sticks usually look more polished than basic multipacks, with neater trimming and fewer weird shapes. They’re still fairly simple and don’t offer extra textures or stronger scent, but they do feel a bit more refined than the lowest-tier budget brands.

Good for cat parents who want “slightly better than generic” without spending much.

8. PurePet Silvervine Sticks

PurePet sells mass-market silvervine sticks with cleaner trimming and packaging than most generic bundles. The quality still depends heavily on the batch, but you do get a more uniform look and fewer overly thin pieces. Cats who like simple bark-on sticks tend to react well enough.

A nice low-cost upgrade from truly random Amazon multipacks.

9. RYERCAT Silvervine Chew Sticks

RYERCAT blew up on TikTok thanks to fun cat reaction videos, and the sticks look cute and playful out of the package. The downside is that quality varies — some packs have great aroma, others barely have scent at all. The materials are similar to other mass-market options without much sorting.

Great for entertainment value but not for consistency.

10. Amazon Generic Multipacks

These bundles are extremely cheap and come under dozens of different names. You get a ton of sticks for the price, but scent strength, size, shape, safety, and finishing are all over the place. Some sticks will work great… others will be complete duds.

Good if you want quantity, not quality.

Final Thoughts

CatTwig gives you a simple raw silvervine stick, but because they’re totally natural and unsorted, reactions can be unpredictable. If you want:

• Stronger scent

• Cleaner, safer materials

• More textures

• Better durability

• Fewer dud sticks

• More consistent engagement

…there are plenty of better options on the market.

If you want the upgrade most cat parents choose after trying the mass-market brands, NomSticks is the safest bet. The consistency and texture variety make a big difference, especially for cats who chew.